I'm not sure if this will help, but it's something I've been working on this week.
My husband (who is a non) was helping me with a flow chart I was making. I needed to see things (past and present) in some kind of concrete format. I kept getting stuck at why did ABUSER do ABUSE. My first block in the flow chart was "because I was bad and deserved it" which led to "I tried harder but it didn't work" and "I couldn't be good enough" and "I'm not good" and "no one would help me" -- it was a whole flow chart along these lines, where I was continually repeating the "try harder" and "still not good enough" or "still bad" or "still deserve it".
My husband said something like, "hang on there is more to a flow chart than this." The said, for example, after "Why did ABUSER do ABUSE" I put "Because I was bad/deserved it" and he said next should be (if it was a flow chart) "Is this true: yes or no" By leaving out this step, I was essentially answering "yes" and carrying on with each step, with the unexamined and unwritten "is this true" always being yes and always leading to the next item I put on the flow chart (try harder, doesn't work, try to explain, doesn't work, etc.)
So he said half the flow chart is totally missing -- the whole challenge part... the NO part.
So he said what if the answer to "I was bad" is this true or not is: NO. Not true. Then I need a new arrow and some new boxes and, in fact, a whole new arm (are they called arms?) of the flow chart. If the answer is "No, I didn't deserve it" then we're back up to "Why did ABUSER do ABUSE" and -- if I'm not bad -- then it must be because THE ABUSER WAS BAD (or wrong or screwed up or mentally ill or whatever -- DH volunteered the adjective "evil" as one option).
I think often we believe the narrative and, to us, there is no other option, no other narrative, no other path to take, no other "arm" to the flow chart. Many of us were brainwashed into thinking this.
Hubby also made another really critical point -- and I think this is where it comes in to your story -- while the original flow chart I had done (my fault - not good enough - try harder - still bad person) was my REALITY it was not TRUE. This was my reality. This is what we lived with and grew up believing and often still believe now -- this is the reality created by long term abusers and it's the reality of anyone with CPTSD. However, it's not TRUE.
It's REAL but it's not TRUE. So it doesn't invalidate our experiences and our feelings. They were very very real and very influential and often feel like the totality of who we are. (I almost always feel either abnormal or bad, although I've spent years perfecting a normal appearance and trying so hard to do good all the time.) This was our reality, but it was a lie... what they said about us were lies... what they made us say to keep up the deception to others were lies... who they said I am was a lie -- none of it was TRUE.
What is true is that the perpetrators did this, the perpetrators are at fault, the perpetrators are to blame for beginning and continuing the abuse, and the perpetrators concocted a lie so big and so overwhelming and so brainwashing that it became almost the very essence of how we see ourselves. But it's a lie.
I kept getting stuck because I kept coming back to the same place over and over, but that was an incomplete narrative. It was my reality -- but it was in complete. It was not the whole story. More needed to be added to make the narrative complete, and that part was where we challenge the narrative that our abusers created and add a completely different section to the narrative: the part where we are good, innocent, where we are trying very hard, the part where we were injured but not bad, we were harmed but we didn't deserve it because that narrative just isn't true.
I'm not sure I'm conveying this well, but I hope it helps. It's kind of a slippery concept for me and sometimes I feel like I grasp it and sometimes I can't and it slips away.
My husband (who is a non) was helping me with a flow chart I was making. I needed to see things (past and present) in some kind of concrete format. I kept getting stuck at why did ABUSER do ABUSE. My first block in the flow chart was "because I was bad and deserved it" which led to "I tried harder but it didn't work" and "I couldn't be good enough" and "I'm not good" and "no one would help me" -- it was a whole flow chart along these lines, where I was continually repeating the "try harder" and "still not good enough" or "still bad" or "still deserve it".
My husband said something like, "hang on there is more to a flow chart than this." The said, for example, after "Why did ABUSER do ABUSE" I put "Because I was bad/deserved it" and he said next should be (if it was a flow chart) "Is this true: yes or no" By leaving out this step, I was essentially answering "yes" and carrying on with each step, with the unexamined and unwritten "is this true" always being yes and always leading to the next item I put on the flow chart (try harder, doesn't work, try to explain, doesn't work, etc.)
So he said half the flow chart is totally missing -- the whole challenge part... the NO part.
So he said what if the answer to "I was bad" is this true or not is: NO. Not true. Then I need a new arrow and some new boxes and, in fact, a whole new arm (are they called arms?) of the flow chart. If the answer is "No, I didn't deserve it" then we're back up to "Why did ABUSER do ABUSE" and -- if I'm not bad -- then it must be because THE ABUSER WAS BAD (or wrong or screwed up or mentally ill or whatever -- DH volunteered the adjective "evil" as one option).
I think often we believe the narrative and, to us, there is no other option, no other narrative, no other path to take, no other "arm" to the flow chart. Many of us were brainwashed into thinking this.
Hubby also made another really critical point -- and I think this is where it comes in to your story -- while the original flow chart I had done (my fault - not good enough - try harder - still bad person) was my REALITY it was not TRUE. This was my reality. This is what we lived with and grew up believing and often still believe now -- this is the reality created by long term abusers and it's the reality of anyone with CPTSD. However, it's not TRUE.
It's REAL but it's not TRUE. So it doesn't invalidate our experiences and our feelings. They were very very real and very influential and often feel like the totality of who we are. (I almost always feel either abnormal or bad, although I've spent years perfecting a normal appearance and trying so hard to do good all the time.) This was our reality, but it was a lie... what they said about us were lies... what they made us say to keep up the deception to others were lies... who they said I am was a lie -- none of it was TRUE.
What is true is that the perpetrators did this, the perpetrators are at fault, the perpetrators are to blame for beginning and continuing the abuse, and the perpetrators concocted a lie so big and so overwhelming and so brainwashing that it became almost the very essence of how we see ourselves. But it's a lie.
I kept getting stuck because I kept coming back to the same place over and over, but that was an incomplete narrative. It was my reality -- but it was in complete. It was not the whole story. More needed to be added to make the narrative complete, and that part was where we challenge the narrative that our abusers created and add a completely different section to the narrative: the part where we are good, innocent, where we are trying very hard, the part where we were injured but not bad, we were harmed but we didn't deserve it because that narrative just isn't true.
I'm not sure I'm conveying this well, but I hope it helps. It's kind of a slippery concept for me and sometimes I feel like I grasp it and sometimes I can't and it slips away.