@Rainagain: You are correct on all counts: the amygdala can't completely evaluate a situation, plan a response, or consider the consequences of a response - it doesn't possess the neuronal functionality to do so; his mates would not have played fair. If you're in a regulated sporting competition with an impartial judge, you can reasonably assume a level of fairness is being applied. Anywhere else? Not a chance.
Consider the following; I've personally found it to be quite true and more importantly, useful.
1.) Immediate, life threatening danger: fist being thrown at you; edged weapon thrusting towards you; firearm being deployed; car running an intersection; gas explosion; bomb or mass shooting; then a life saving 45ms response is warranted. When you primal do it to the maximum!
2.) Anything that requires 0.5s response or more, engage the PFC. Standing up, walking around a table to confront someone - warranted or not - engage the PFC. Evaluate the entire situation and your options fully.
3.) Sometimes 1 followed closely by 2 is the most appropriate course of action.
Here's a useful trick: program a PFC code word into your head. Mine is 'Monk'. When I was on active duty and we engaged in a crisis situation my partner and I would code each other out of a primal response - if required. If you have a trustworthy friend that you usually socialise with you can ask them to code you if you go primal.
Be safe. LTLTR
Consider the following; I've personally found it to be quite true and more importantly, useful.
1.) Immediate, life threatening danger: fist being thrown at you; edged weapon thrusting towards you; firearm being deployed; car running an intersection; gas explosion; bomb or mass shooting; then a life saving 45ms response is warranted. When you primal do it to the maximum!
2.) Anything that requires 0.5s response or more, engage the PFC. Standing up, walking around a table to confront someone - warranted or not - engage the PFC. Evaluate the entire situation and your options fully.
3.) Sometimes 1 followed closely by 2 is the most appropriate course of action.
Here's a useful trick: program a PFC code word into your head. Mine is 'Monk'. When I was on active duty and we engaged in a crisis situation my partner and I would code each other out of a primal response - if required. If you have a trustworthy friend that you usually socialise with you can ask them to code you if you go primal.
Be safe. LTLTR